Save the California Delta Alliance (STCDA)

The federal and state departments are about to hustle the “2-Gates Fish Protection Project” through. This project will potentially ruin water quality in this area, which will severely impact home values. It may even negatively impact your health (read item 3 below).

The following are examples of letters/e-mails that you may want to send during the public comment period. Please send at least one e-mail opposing the project, and PLEASE, reword them. If they appear to be form letters, they will only be counted as one item. Please forward this to others.

There are four sample items below. Each is potentially a separate e-mail. Choose one or more, but PLEASE do not send them as one item. To make this easy, we have two versions of each letter:

• the first link is the text. Review and and copy/paste it into an email, modify as you see fit
• the second link is a PDF document that you can print and mail

1. Sample Letter #1, (pdf)
2. Sample Letter #2, (pdf)
3. Sample Letter #3, (pdf)
4. Sample Letter #4, (pdf)

Send your comment to: MManzo@usbr.gov BEFORE 11/17/09. Make certain that the subject line has the following information (if you click the link above, the subject line will be set already) :

Public Comment – 2-Gates Fish Protection Demonstration Project

If we are to save the Delta from those gates, we need you. We ask only that you voice your opinion, everyone counts.
Thanks for your help.

The US Army Corps of Engineers has posted Public Notice “SPK-2009-01197”, which describes the engineering side of the Two Gates project, including detailed construction plans. The notice says that the

The announcement email reads:

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Sacramento District has posted Public Notice SPK-2009-01197 to http://www.spk.usace.army.mil/regulatory.html

San Luis and Delta Mendota Water Authority, Ara Azhderian has applied for a permit to place dredged or fill material and work in approximately 1.97 acres of waters of the United States to construct 2 temporary operable gate structures. This 5 year project would test if such structures could reduce entrainment of sensitive fish species at the State (SWP) and Federal (CVP) water export facilities. This project is located on Old River and Connection Slough, Sec 30, T2N, R4E, and Sec 22, T2N, R4E San Joaquin and Contra Costa Counties, California.

Written comments and/or a request for a paper copy of the notice may be submitted to project manager William Guthrie at, email William.H.Guthrie@usace.army.mil, or telephone 916-557-5269.

Comments must be received by November 30, 2009.

The public notice SPK-2009-01197, concerning the Two Gates project can be found under this link, and the engineering plans and drawings can be found here, showing how far this project has been progressing already.

_{PS: The link in the email notice is not correct, the correct link for current public notices with the US ACE is here.}

by Amanda Dove, Editor In Chief, Delta Sun Times

DISCOVERY BAY
Concerned citizens from Discovery Bay and around the Delta filled the gymnasium at Discovery Bay School Tuesday night. The crowd (of approx. 600) hoped to dissuade the Bureau of Reclamation from continuing forward with plans to build two gates at Old River and Connection Slough, which will virtually cut off Discovery Bay from 1,100 miles of navigable Delta waterways. Concerns about the Two Gates project are serious. The project will almost certainly threaten Discovery Bay ’s water quality, aquatic life, boater safety, and the overall health of the Delta in the long-term. Property values, business survival and quality of life in the community of 17,000 residents are at stake.

The Two-Gates project is an $80 million dollar experiment, proposed to remain in place for five years. The experiment, proposed by (and paid for) by southern California water concerns and land developers, is a part of the California Department of Natural Resources modeling elements for the extremely controversial Peripheral Canal. If the two gates project can demonstrate it helps to protect the Delta’s endangered smelt population, this will help the Peripheral Canal project along in the approval process. The project is clearly pitched as a “Save the Smelt” project.
Discovery Bay Chamber of Commerce president-elect, Greg Spivak, put it well: “I’m amazed that Southern California is so concerned about these tiny fish that live only here, in the Northern California Delta.” This statement was echoed throughout the night, as speakers from the crowd stated again and again that this project is about increasing water to Southern California residents.

Many left frustrated, as it was clear that the Bureau of Reclamation intends to proceed with this project, despite dozens of legitimate concerns, and questions of the science and research that is actually in place for this project. The real concerns over the lack of research on the impact in Discovery Bay clearly demonstrates the need for an Environmental Impact Report, a move that Reclamation officials said they “would wrestle with” (whether or not it is needed). The Two Gates project must still obtain a permit from the Army Corps of Engineers, a last stop for public comment, which will likely take place within a month’s time. This will be an essential moment in Discovery Bay history. Even five years could change the Delta and Discovery Bay forever. Changing tidal flows and fish migration could lead to lack of fish and wildlife in the southern Delta, increased aquatic plant life growth (which is already inundating Discovery Bay), and decreased water quality (muddy and/or smelly water) due to the stagnate water that could result from stopping water flow 10-20 hours per day.

Even with all of the environmental impact concerns, boaters will be most affected. Boats would not be able to freely pass through these gated areas, forcing southern Delta boaters hours further to the east and north to reach their destinations. Those trying to reach Discovery Bay and the surrounding area would be severely deterred from making the effort to travel so far. Marinas such as Holland Riverside, Orwood Resort and Discovery Bay Marina would be the last place one might want to berth their vessel, being the furthest point away from the most desired destinations to the west.

Stay informed, write your elected officials, the Bureau of Reclamation, and the Army Corps of Engineers.

Further information:

• Bureau of Reclamation 2-Gates Fish Protection Demonstration Project page
• US Bureau of Reclamation: Information Sheet
• US Bureau of Reclamation: Project News Rooms
• US Bureau of Reclamation: 2-Gates Fish Protection Demonstration Project Environmental Assessment documents

The Two-Gates project is being pushed forward, now supported by Diane Feinstein as part of a California Water Crisis initiative using U.S. stimulus money. The Two-Gates will close off Old River and Connection Slough up to 20 hours/day.

Since the closing is tide-based and varies, it will be difficult for boaters to know when they are open and when they are closed. This will severely impact recreational boating, impact safety rescue operations (coast guard, marine sheriffs – could cost lives), impact local economies, (e.g., increased time/cost to get pile drivers down from Bethel to Discovery Bay, marina operators will lose business when boaters cannot get from one Marina to their favorite boating/fishing sites, etc., etc.). The list of concerns and issues with installing gates in primary navigation waterways is long and significant. In short, the gates will isolate Discovery Bay by periodically closing off the only unbridged waterway from here to the rest of the Delta thus could easily end up impacting our home values as well as our boating safety.

And for what reason? The purpose behind installing the 2-Gates is to increase the export of water from the Delta to Central and Southern California – even though the past years of excessive exporting of water has been steadily ruining the entire Delta ecosystem, resulting in a ban on Commercial Salmon fishing along the entire California/Oregon coast the past two years, and will soon impact the water in our own back yards, changing our fresh water river to brackish, salty, polluted water. Which will pollute our wells, OUR drinking water. A VERY scary thought! The current approaches are NOT the right way to solve California ’s water crisis.

What can we do to stop the spending of money on short-sighted measures that are destroying the Delta and will significantly impact our Delta communities and our way of life?

1. First, the Draft Environmental Assessment (EA) for the 2-Gates Fish Protection Demonstration Project is now planned to be posted on the Bureau of Reclamations’ 2-Gates website at http://www.usbr.gov/mp/2gates/ Monday, October 19 for a 30-day public review and comment period. POST YOUR COMMENTS.
2. Forward this email to anyone you know in Discovery Bay and encourage them to show up at the meeting – and email to all boaters in other towns in the Delta and throughout Northern California to let them know this is happening so they too can comment on the website.
3. Go to the websites for Senators Feinstein and Boxer, Nancy Pelosi, John Garamendi (potential replacement for Ellen Tauscher), and the Governor and PROTEST. Let them know we do NOT want US Stimulus money spent to restrict the waterways in/out of Discovery Bay :

• Diane Feinstein – contact http://feinstein.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=ContactUs.EmailMe
• Barbara Boxer – contact https://boxer.senate.gov/contact/email/policy.cfm
• Nancy Pelosi – contact http://www.house.gov/pelosi/contact/contact.html
• John Garamendi – email info@garamendi.com
• Governor Schwarzenegger – contact http://gov.ca.gov/interact